What is Incrementality in Marketing? The Ultimate Guide for 2024

In today’s complex marketing landscape, understanding the true impact of your campaigns is crucial. But how can you be sure that your marketing efforts are actually driving growth? This is where incrementality comes in. Incrementality testing helps marketers measure the additional impact of their marketing activities, ensuring that every dollar spent contributes to real business outcomes.

What is Incrementality in Marketing?

Incrementality in marketing refers to the additional impact that a specific marketing activity has on a key performance indicator (KPI) beyond what would have happened without that activity. In other words, it’s the measure of the true effectiveness of your marketing efforts—whether they are driving new sales, sign-ups, or other desired actions that wouldn’t have occurred without your intervention.

For example, if you run a campaign that results in 10,000 conversions, but 7,000 of those would have happened anyway without the campaign, the incremental impact of your campaign is 3,000 conversions. Understanding this distinction is crucial for optimizing your marketing spend and driving real growth.

Why is Incrementality Important for Marketers?

How Can Incrementality Testing Help Optimize Marketing Spend?

Incrementality testing allows marketers to understand which aspects of their marketing efforts are truly contributing to growth. By isolating the effects of specific campaigns, channels, or tactics, incrementality helps you determine where your budget is best spent. Without this understanding, you risk allocating funds to activities that merely claim credit for actions that would have occurred anyway.

What Questions Can Incrementality Testing Answer?

Incrementality testing can help answer a variety of critical questions, such as:

• Which marketing channels are driving the most incremental revenue?
• What will happen if I reduce or increase my spend in a particular channel?
• Are my ads contributing to new sales, or are they just capturing existing demand?
• How effective is a new marketing tactic compared to existing strategies?

These insights empower marketers to make data-driven decisions that optimize their marketing mix, enhance ROI, and improve overall campaign effectiveness.

How Does Incrementality Differ from Attribution?

What is the Difference Between Attribution and Incrementality?

Attribution and incrementality are related concepts but serve different purposes. Attribution involves tracking which marketing channels or touchpoints lead to conversions, typically using models like last-touch or multi-touch attribution. However, attribution doesn’t account for whether these conversions would have happened without the marketing intervention.

Incrementality, on the other hand, focuses on the additional impact or lift that a marketing activity generates. While attribution tells you where conversions are happening, incrementality tells you whether those conversions are truly driven by your marketing efforts.

Can Attribution and Incrementality Work Together?

Absolutely. Attribution and incrementality can complement each other. Attribution helps you understand the customer journey and how different touchpoints contribute to conversions. Incrementality testing then validates whether these touchpoints are driving new, incremental value, helping you refine your attribution models and make more informed marketing decisions.

How to Conduct Incrementality Testing?

What Are the Steps to Start Incrementality Testing?

Conducting an incrementality test involves several key steps:

1. Design the Experiment:
   • Create a randomized controlled experiment with a test group (exposed to the marketing campaign) and a control group (not exposed).
   • Ensure that the groups are comparable to avoid selection bias.
2. Select Metrics:
   • Identify the primary KPIs you want to measure, such as conversion rate, sales, or ROAS (Return on Ad Spend).
3. Run the Test:
   • Implement the marketing campaign for the test group while ensuring the control group remains unaffected.
   • Use techniques like geographic targeting, audience segmentation, or synthetic control groups to isolate the impact.
4. Measure Results:
   • After the campaign, compare the performance of the test group against the control group.
   • The difference in outcomes is the incremental impact of the marketing campaign.
5. Analyze and Optimize:
   • Use the insights gained to refine your marketing strategies, reallocating budget to the most effective channels and tactics.

What Are Some Advanced Techniques in Incrementality Testing?

While basic incrementality testing provides valuable insights, more advanced techniques can offer deeper analysis:

• Propensity Score Matching: This method helps create more accurate control groups by matching users based on their likelihood to convert.
• Regression Analysis: Useful for isolating the impact of multiple variables on your incremental lift.
• Time-Series Analysis: Helps track how incremental lift changes over time, offering insights into long-term campaign effectiveness.

What Are Common Challenges in Incrementality Testing?

How to Address Selection Bias in Incrementality Testing?

Selection bias occurs when the test and control groups are not truly comparable, leading to skewed results. To mitigate this, ensure that the groups are randomized and matched as closely as possible on key characteristics. Techniques like propensity score matching can help create balanced groups that provide more accurate comparisons.

What External Factors Can Affect Incrementality Testing?

External factors such as seasonality, economic conditions, or even weather can influence the results of your incrementality tests. It’s important to account for these variables when designing your experiment and interpreting the results. For instance, running a test during a major holiday season might produce different outcomes than during a slow sales period.

How Can Data Quality Impact Incrementality Testing?

High-quality data is critical for accurate incrementality testing. Poor data quality can lead to incorrect conclusions, wasting valuable marketing resources. Ensure that your data is clean, consistent, and representative of your target audience. Regularly validate your data to maintain the integrity of your incrementality tests.

What Are Some Creative Uses of Incrementality Testing?

How Can Incrementality Testing Improve Your Email Marketing Strategy?

By conducting regional email holdout tests, you can segment your email list by region and hold out retention emails in certain areas. This allows you to measure the incremental impact of your email marketing campaigns on repeat purchases, helping you understand how much your emails are truly driving additional orders versus what would have happened organically.

Can Incrementality Testing Help Optimize Product Bundling?

Yes, product bundle incrementality tests can reveal whether offering product bundles or package deals leads to higher average order values and increased customer lifetime value. By comparing groups exposed to bundles with those presented with individual products, you can determine the most effective sales strategy.

How Can Incrementality Testing Enhance Your Loyalty Program?

Loyalty program tier testing allows you to assign customers to different loyalty program tiers randomly. By measuring the incremental impact on purchase behavior and customer retention, you can optimize your loyalty program to maximize its effectiveness.

What is the Best Time to Start Incrementality Testing?

When Should You Begin Incrementality Testing?

Incrementality testing is most effective for businesses with substantial marketing activity and ad spend. As a rule of thumb, we recommend starting incrementality testing if your ad spend exceeds $90,000 per month per channel. For businesses with lower ad spend, the incremental impact might be too small to measure effectively, and other optimization strategies may be more appropriate.

How Can Stella Help with Incrementality Testing?

Stella is the most powerful yet affordable incrementality measurement tool on the market, designed to help businesses of all sizes get started with incrementality testing. Stella’s platform is user-friendly, making it accessible for beginners while providing advanced features for more experienced marketers. With Stella, you can easily analyze your data, find the best holdout regions, and reach statistical significance in the shortest amount of time.

Conclusion: Why Incrementality is the Key to Marketing Success

Incrementality testing is not just another buzzword—it’s a critical tool for understanding the true impact of your marketing efforts. By measuring what truly drives growth, incrementality testing allows you to optimize your marketing strategy, allocate your budget more effectively, and ultimately achieve better business outcomes. Whether you’re new to incrementality or looking to refine your approach, tools like Stella make it easier than ever to start measuring and optimizing for incremental success.

‍